3 basic proposals to (largely) prevent light pollution. (Summary: let's turn the lights off after 24:00.)
· PLD Türkiye
Automatically translated from Turkish. Read the original
Since 2012 I've been working so that awareness of light pollution grows, and so that more people hear about the subject. In the last piece I wrote, titled “What is light pollution? The work in Türkiye”, I both went over the definition again and touched on the work being done in Türkiye. See: https://pldturkiye.com/isik-kirliligi-nedir-turkiyedeki-calismalar/
What I want to do in this piece is to bring 3 basic proposals that could remove this problem to a large extent, and to set a new starting point for the debates and for the regulations that could be made. More precisely, I want to focus on the details of applying a single proposal - turning the lights off after 24:00 - in 3 different areas.
There are 3 different elements that make up the source of light pollution.
1- Architectural lighting:
First we have to accept that light, like sound, is a matter of public space. Just as you are bound by certain rules for the use of sound, whether inside your building or outside it, the use of light cannot be left to your wishes alone either.
For example, a façade lighting you apply so that your building draws attention creates a constant pollution for the thousands of people who have to look at your building. The multicoloured, high-power LEDs you use because you personally like them, or because you believe they do you commercial good, actually mean a constant “carnival” for us neighbours who live right across the way. You forget that there are people who have to look all night at this design you liked after looking at it for 5 minutes.
As in the 2009 Light Pollution Bill of Zeki Aslan Hoca (hoca is how Turks address a respected teacher), having every outdoor lighting project submitted to a board and approved looks like a hard but ideal solution. http://www.isikkirliligi.org/index.php/kaynaklar/19-tug-isik-kirliligi-kanun-tasarisi-taslagi
What I offer is a simpler solution, and one that can be applied quickly. My proposal holds even if there is a board. Whether it belongs to a public body or a private one, every outdoor lighting element should be turned off after 24:00.
Some details can differ. Permission can run until 24:00 on weekdays and until 01:00 at the weekend, while on special days (such as New Year) they can stay on until morning.
What I'm saying also holds for an unused park, or for offices and plazas where, because of the glass, all the interior lighting is experienced from outside too. But it is (of course) not about street, tunnel or square lighting.
2- Illuminated sign:
Businesses use signs entirely for advertising. These signs containing LEDs, or being lit in general, also turn the advert into a 24-hour one.
First, an illuminated sign should be subject to an extra tax. I may not know the details, but I know that a sign is already subject to a tax. I would guess that the size of the sign matters at this point too. That is, there is a tax by size, and the size a sign may reach is proportional to the building, or to the area the business occupies in that building. (I hope) Anyway, being illuminated should also have a place in this tax detail, and it should have a cost.
And of course, all illuminated signs should be turned off after 24:00. The only exception here might be the business being open after 24:00. If it is open at that hour, people knowing that it exists will be an important point.
3- LED screen:
LED screens are a point that really makes no sense to me. I want to go forward with the sound example again. Just as I shouldn't be able to put very powerful loudspeakers on my building and broadcast for 24 hours, “I'm here, I have products like this, I have products like that”, I shouldn't be able to install an LED screen and keep it on for 24 hours either. I'd like to give a very current example. The LED screen placed on the back face of the building called Quasar, in Mecidiyeköy, İstanbul, is an advertising medium that addresses almost the whole Bosphorus. I constantly hear complaints from friends who live in that area, but I don't think any sanction has been applied, or can be. So how can one building's decision affect the whole Bosphorus? If this isn't a trespass on public space, what is?
And, yes, every LED screen, this time with no exception, should be turned off after 24:00.
The subjects and the proposals I've mentioned are so simple, aren't they? Yes, I think so too. But when it comes to putting them into practice, never mind these: despite the effort shown for years, not the slightest progress has yet been made against light pollution. Even these proposals alone mean a solution for a large part of the problem.
That's why I want these proposals to form a starting point, and for us to move on towards more considered, planned solutions. But let's start somewhere first. And I can't think of an easier place to start.
My request of you is that you share these proposals with the people around you, and carry them to as many places as you can.
As I said in my previous piece: “Light pollution is actually a problem whose solution has no losers, so every step we take on it will bring good results for all of us.”