An Ankara tale

· PLD Türkiye

Automatically translated from Turkish. Read the original

For some time I have been following, on Twitter, the Department of Urban Aesthetics, which sits under Ankara Metropolitan Municipality. (@ABBKentEst) As a unit, they do “decorative” work for our distinguished capital, Ankara, especially as they put it in every tweet. They share photos of clock towers, gates, swan statues and, of course, various building lightings. The adjective they share is “decorative”.

On 31 October they posted this tweet:

“Ankara has come first, competing with the capitals of the world in the World Lighting Competition. www.peoplechoiceaward.eu” (See: https://twitter.com/ABBKentEst/status/528104162639499264/photo/1)

When I clicked the link, some details came out. A competition held since 2003 by Philips and the International Association of City Lighting (LUCI, www.luciassociation.org), under the name “The city.people.light award” (City.People.Light), to bring forward the effects of light on people and on the city. It works like this: city administrations apply with the lighting projects they carried out that year. First, some of the projects evaluated by a jury reach the final, and the winner is chosen by a “public vote” held on the internet. Some of the projects evaluated by a jury reach the final, and awards are given to 3 cities. This year 35 projects from 25 countries entered the competition, 16 countries reached the final, and Leipzig, in Germany, took first place, with 2nd Copenhagen (Denmark) and 3rd Strasbourg (France). But this year, for the first time, among the countries that reached the final, a "people.choice.award" by "public vote" is also given, and Ankara comes first with the high share of the vote it received. came.

At this point, 2 things draw attention.

First, the text on the site that presents Ankara:

“With a lighting master plan, architectural harmony was created between the different buildings in the city. The warm and elegant ambience, created using smart white light technology, shows respect for the night. For some architectural works, more colourful designs were preferred. The scheme created a positive effect on residents and visitors by forming modern silhouettes that enrich the city's identity, and safe and attractive areas.”

Does Ankara have a lighting master plan? (If it does, who prepared it?) Does it show respect for the night? Smart white light? It is as if a different city is being talked about.

The second point is the share of the vote, city by city:
1. Ankara / Türkiye: 239,875
2. Pula / Croatia: 114,776
3. Toledo / Spain: 95,071
4. Skopje / Macedonia: 17,532

The remaining shares of the vote range from 100 to 1,000. For example, cities such as Lyon, Copenhagen and London, which have lighting master plans of 20 to 30 years and are known for successful lighting projects, received around 400 votes. Don't you also find it interesting that the votes run in inverse proportion to how developed the countries are? As the site stands, it is impossible to really judge the projects. There is a short text and a few images. (NOTE: Voting is over. Perhaps at the time there were more images and more explanation.) For example, it is said that Ankara applied with 22 projects and took first place with 1 project. Which project, I wonder?

For a long time I have followed Ankara, Mayor Melih Gökçek, and his statements about lighting. From time to time I have also written pieces that point out the problems that exist. So for me, never mind Ankara receiving an award: even the words Ankara, lighting and award appearing in the same sentence could, at most, be an Ankara tale.

Stay with the light until our next issue...


PLD Türkiye

NOTE: The struck-through expressions are corrections made on 17 November. I apologise for the error.