Anti-context
· PLD Türkiye
Automatically translated from Turkish. Read the original
“Aiming to stress the positive effect of design on production, on economic development, on social and societal progress, on cultural interaction and on the quality of individuals' lives, the first İstanbul Design Biennial will be held in 2012.”
The sentence you have just read is a quotation from the website of the İstanbul Design Biennial, which İKSV will hold from 13 October to 12 December 2012... The theme is “Kusurluluk / Imperfection”. How exciting...
The first biennial has two curators. Joseph Grima, editor-in-chief of Domus magazine, an architect, editor, writer and curator who continues his work in Milan, and Emre Arolat, founding partner of Emre Arolat Architects (EAA), an architect with many national and international awards.... Last week the biennial process began, with the open calls the curators wrote. The problem Emre Arolat sets out under the subheading “Anti-context” is, “to me”, an open wound of the lighting industry too.
First, a quotation: “What is opened for discussion is how this tendency, taken by a large part of the design world as a revolutionary condition, and which, while it widens its borders day by day with the talismanic charm it puts forward, exalts only what is out of the ordinary, almost without regard to quality, can polish every surface and at the same time soften the sharp corners; how it can make industrial design products, works of architecture, even cities, all the same, even though it set out to produce a series of differences; and thus how, in the end, it is in a way shot with its own weapon.” (To reach the full text: http://bit.ly/musibet)
In plain words, I read the text like this: the problem of the abilities of LED technology, called revolutionary, being reduced to changing colour, and of buildings that, in the name of being different, turn uniform and sadly take over the whole city, the buildings in every colour. This problem has been going on for a while and grows day by day, and it has two basic causes:
The first cause is simple: LEDs are very capable. We are talking about a light source you can draw enough arguments from to adorn a marketer's dreams. Set against other light sources, it stands out both for its long life and its low use of energy, and, for the mercury it does not contain, it looks kinder to the environment. Once you have also solved the disadvantages, the cost of the first investment, the problems of standardisation, the quality of the light, it is possible to see an LED light source in almost every project. Indeed, many projects are now started with LED to be used, without anyone looking at the design. And sadly, on top of all this, these clever little diodes can change colour. So our lives fill up with buildings that change colour mindlessly, with no context, no reason and no design thought.
The second cause is this: the problem of localisation under the effect of globalisation showing itself in lighting too. While one of our mayors, after a trip to Singapore that filled him with admiration, says he is thinking of lighting Ankara this way within two years, it does not occur to him, it cannot, that the use of colour may be read differently in different cultures, and, at its simplest, that the Turkish people are not very much at home with too much colour. Our brain stands waiting, ready to say “It's become like a pavyon” (the seedy Turkish nightclub) of every idea with too much colour. And it is impossible to say that pavyons are seen in a positive way. The moment you forget that the process of lighting design is made of a cultural past, of habits, of experience, you also break the tie between the clothes you have put on and the owner of the body.
That being so, a way of designing built on showing what LED can do offers us plastic, fake and contextless lighting of spaces and cities. What matters, though, is the fact that lighting design defines the relationship between the space and the user, drawing on many different disciplines, such as sociology and psychology. The light source to be used is a decision made after the design. Many times I have written it, and it seems I will go on writing it: before everything else, design comes, friends. Let's not forget!..
Stay with the light until our next issue…
Emre Güneş
Professional Lighting Design Türkiye