Bright and shining...

· PLD Türkiye

Automatically translated from Turkish. Read the original

emre-gunes-pld-turkiyeAt first our cities were dark. As lighting technology developed, our cities lit up too. Every piece that came out of the dark pleased us. How lovely, we said, it had become bright and shining . “Bright and shining” became the first adjective that came to mind as praise for a project at night. Lighting a space was enough for praise. Because we were used to the dark. After a while it stuck to our tongues, the way every adjective does once it settles. It still turns up in the predictable headlines of many press releases. Building X bright and shining with company X.

Then, as technology developed, our cities began to be lit. The lighting of public space, advancing step by step through London, Paris and so on, got out of control after a while. As technology developed, and as light came to be used as advertising, the process this time turned the other way. Through competition, ignorance and the power of marketing, we lit everywhere, and more than was needed. We came to miss the dark, and the moonlight. The light dazzled us. We started taking photographs of our world from space and talking about light pollution. (At this point the very idea of light pollution ought to be debated, because light does not pollute, there is no light pollution, there is unwanted (spam) light. But that is a subject for another article.) Bless them: with LEDs joining our ranks as well, and joining strongly, colour change became a fact of our lives. That is why, today, bright and shining is not praise as far as I'm concerned. It is not a concept that defines correct lighting at all.

Our subject is shadow design. Shadow and light, however much they look like opposites at first glance, are in fact ideas that complete each other. At night, the most effective way to bring one detail out is to leave the others in shadow. A sense of space, and of dimension, is possible only with shadows. The power of lighting design comes, after all, from deciding what it wants us to look at, or to see. So shadows play an important part in correct lighting, which is also to say that it isn't true that the brighter a place is, the better.

We have to share this fact with the people around us. We urgently need to tell people that a lot of light is not the right light. But we have to tell everyone. That is, everyone, from public officials to the architect, from the owner of the capital to the man in the street… We even have to tell the people who work in the lighting industry, so that we don't live through the example below again.

Some of you may have seen it. The Haydarpaşa Campus of Marmara University was lit this year as part of the preparations for İstanbul 2010 European Capital of Culture. I had the chance to follow closely the lighting of this building, which I pass every day on my way home. Of course everyone will have a different view of the design. I don't want to debate that here. But I will have comments on the approach taken in presenting the project. I had been waiting curiously to learn who had carried it out, and when I saw the project's press release I couldn't believe my eyes. In the press release, for the project completed for about 2.1 million YTL , the part mentioned with praise was the number of luminaires and LEDs used. For the first time in Europe, a little over 3,000 LED luminaires had been used on a single project. In other words, if still more luminaires could have been fitted to the building, an even more successful project could have been carried out. That is the meaning I take from it. When this is the thing being boasted about, I suppose we shouldn't be surprised that the budget came to 2.1 million YTL either. And in that sense the project is so successful that, by a new decision taken because of the rising electricity cost, the new design is used only 3 days a week.

If anyone asks the headline of the press release, I'll tell you: “Haydarpaşa, bright and shining”(!).