Cooperation and competition

· PLD Türkiye

Automatically translated from Turkish. Read the original

Can the ideas of cooperation and competition intertwine? Join the English words "cooperation" and "competition" and you arrive at the idea of "Co-Opetition". Barry Nalebuff, a Yale professor who gave the idea its name with the book he wrote in 1996, explains the philosophy of Co-Opetition like this: "Cooperate to grow the pie, compete to share it"

In fact the approach goes back as far as "Game Theory", which emerged during the Second World War.
At base, classical trade has a winner and a loser, while with this approach the players in the market move together and maximise the total profit. An example I took from Hakan Baş's article, which I read recently, is clear enough. He draws attention with successful ventures such as Krombera, Lidyana and PeakGames: "As an example, one can give Coca Cola and Pepsi cooperating to tell the public that cola is a harmless drink, thus growing the market, while racing each other in advertising and promotion to increase their market shares. For the ecosystem to develop, firms in the same industry must not, while they compete, ignore the industry-wide benefits they can gain from cooperation."

So what does all this have to do with the lighting industry? As a lighting industry we have a single problem, and in this sense a simple one: We are not taken seriously. We labour in a field that is defined as circles on the drawing, whose responsibility is unclear, and that even many building professionals, with the logic of "as long as it lights, that's enough", remember only when the budget is spent and the building is already there. When that is the case, it becomes "normal" for competition to focus entirely on "price", for anyone who can bring a container of goods from China to enter the market, or for buyers to send the same lighting project out to the whole industry. What faces us is a problem impossible to solve by the separate efforts of the industry's players.

And in front of us there is both a great opportunity and a great danger: LED... Thanks to abilities you would not expect from its tiny size, and thanks to this light source that everyone is watching, the lighting industry is getting more attention than perhaps at any time in its history. Everyone wants LED. Because it can be controlled, it changes colour, it is sustainable, it lasts a long time, and so on… What answers this huge demand is a huge cloud of dust. Sadly, despite various efforts, standards for LED have not been set. I will say it very plainly: nobody, but nobody, including our important manufacturers, fully has a grip on the process. There is information pollution, and it just goes on. While every person and every mind used to conventional light sources struggles to adapt, what to compare with what, and how to calculate efficiency, meet us as unsettled ideas. The market is waiting to be regulated.

Right at this point, what we need is clear: "Co-Opetition". Today, without losing any time, we should come together and raise our voices higher than ever!.. Even if we cannot say what is right, we should say what may be wrong, and start an awareness campaign that takes in every actor. As a great Turkish thinker said, "Quickly, quickly, but without rushing"...

Stay with the light until our next issue…


Professional Lighting Design Türkiye