Light Emitting Diode
· PLD Türkiye
Automatically translated from Turkish. Read the original
As a magazine we are going through a busy period. First the Light&Building fair and the ash cloud that stretched our trip, then the İstanbul Yapı Fuarı, the start of the LightMapping event, the New Trends in Architectural Lighting Conference, and a high-paced rush packed into two months.
Light&Building carries on, as always, in its duty as the temple of the architectural lighting community. Meeting, in Frankfurt, people I never get the chance to speak with face to face in Türkiye has become a tradition. I won't go into much detail on the fair, because in this issue the young lighting designer Faruk Uyan reviews it and shares his thoughts. But, as 9 out of 10 people who went to the fair would say, it was impossible not to see the dominance of LED technology. All through the fair, LED (Light Emitting Diode) was the apple of every manufacturer's eye, while the common point of the marketing lines was “sustainability” and “energy efficiency” . Amid all this wind, I am one of those who keep as much distance from LED as they can. Given where the technology has got to, what LED offers is plain to see. The flexibility it brings to design, its long life… (advantages you could read in any manufacturer's catalogue). To ignore these, you would have to put on blinkers. Of course, like every novelty, along with its advantages it also brings some question marks.
There are a few reasons for this. They are subjects woven into one another, but I think it will be more illuminating to take them under headings.
1. Marketing: All over the world, the idea of “energy efficiency”, as was done before with compact fluorescent lamps, is being reduced to the use of LED. I object! Energy efficiency calls for a whole approach to design. It also takes in stages such as the use of daylight, a lighting control system, and the use of technology according to the function. Haven't you burned your mouth before on that “Change it, save” logic?
2. Uncertainty: LED technology is a technology that is constantly being worked on, and that is still developing at every moment. That being so, even our manufacturers struggle to keep up with the developments. At this point it is hard to find the right moment to make the decision to buy. While a more powerful and/or longer-lived version may come out at any time, how much sense does it make to invest in an LED system by paying large budgets? There is no doubt they are long-lived, but at this pace of development, will you want to use the same luminaires until their life is up?
3. Standard: Perhaps one of the most important obstacles in front of LED technology is standardisation. Today the quality of an LED luminaire depends entirely on the manufacturer's standards. For example, only your manufacturer's quality decides whether the colour an LED luminaire gives will still be the same tone 5 years on. And it is not yet possible to interchange the products of two manufacturers, that is, to buy the luminaire from one and the lamp from another. The international ZHAGA project, which goes on with the joint effort of the whole industry, continues on this.
Further information: http://www.zhagastandard.org/
4. Trust: As with every popular subject, when the level of awareness about LED is not very high, the opportunists appear in the same way. Once quality is given up in a product that is easy to market and easy to consume, the number of customers who come to regret it grows too. Sadly, the bad experiences of both designers and of the owners of capital who stand as the client can turn them against the technology. I think it will take a while to build trust in the product and in the technology.
These points I have summed up may be negative judgements, about LEDs as the technology of the future, that need to be looked at in detail in a long article rather than in a column. But my aim is not to sway your views on LED anyway. It is to pass on my own observations.
This needs underlining. Before everything else, design comes. The technologies and the light sources that suit the design are thought about in parallel. Decide on the technology first and then make a design to fit it: you can't, and you must not.
Stay with the light until our next issue…
Emre Güneş
Professional Lighting Design Türkiye