Lighting, the stepchild

· PLD Türkiye

Automatically translated from Turkish. Read the original

Years ago, during the Light&Building fair in Frankfurt, an important industry veteran who works internationally, and whom I was talking with, said something like this: "The lighting industry was basically nothing but metal bent over a light source / lamp. With LED, everything changed"

Really, before the LED revolution, when there was not much variety of light source / lamp, life was easier for all of us as industry professionals. For light quality we had very good light sources, such as the halogen and incandescent lamp. (We still do, but our statesmen banned them to save the bears at the North Pole. Of course, it is telling that, for the ban, they chose the poor bulb and not the 4x4 jeeps.) Depending on the application, we had alternatives such as fluorescent, compact fluorescent, metal halide or sodium vapour lamps. And for every one of these light sources there were few brands, and there were established standards.

When LED entered general lighting as a light source, we opened our eyes to a whole new world. What you can do with LED really is unlimited. There is no point debating the advantages it brings in application and in efficiency. But the speed of LED's development is so uncontrolled that, like a cloud of dust, it is hard to follow even for very experienced industry professionals.

At its core, lighting is a system solution. With LED, compatibility of the driver and the control system meets us as another difficulty. Knowing what works with what, and keeping up with it, is just as tiring. Lighting designers who know light very well, but who could approach the subject on the basis of the 50W, 75W and 100W lamp, now have to head towards becoming "a technology guru".

Say we did keep up. How are we going to explain our trouble to the end user? In our effort to persuade the customer to buy a better product, the factors we have to explain have multiplied along with LEDs whose standards are still unclear. On top of points such as reflector quality and production method, we now have to talk about ideas I am sure even many industry professionals don't know, such as CRI (Color Rendering Index), MacAdam Ellipse, GAI (Gamut Area Index) and CQS (Color Quality System).

Already, as the "stepchild" lighting industry, we come to mind when the building, the time and the money have run out. For a lighting detail that nobody takes seriously, the customer has neither the time nor the wish to listen to all these three-letter concepts.

On the other side are our manufacturers' efforts to industrialise. To industrialise means standard production. Lighting, by its nature, already makes standardisation hard. The wishes of the architect or the end user, "if only that part were like this", never end. Add a supply chain with this much variation in price and product, and how will you standardise production, how will you hold stock, and how will you manufacture quickly? So we should not be surprised by the news that some large European manufacturers are leaving the industry because profits are falling.

As Bülent Ortaçgil said, "This job is very hard, Yonca"... And today more than it has ever been. The bad news is that it does not look as if it will change in the short term either.

Stay with the light until our next issue...


PLD Türkiye