One step forward, one step back
· PLD Türkiye
Automatically translated from Turkish. Read the original
When I heard, in late 2006, that a lighting department would open within the İstanbul Metropolitan Municipality, I got very excited. It had been 2 years since PLD Türkiye magazine came out. The events I joined internationally, and the publications I followed, all pointed to the same place: every city in the world that is spoken of together with light had a lighting department. There was even an association where municipalities that carry out work on light come together and exchange ideas. At that date, the LUCI (Lighting Urban Community International) association, based in Lyon, had more than 30 members. (Right now this number is 67)
Inside a picture like this, the idea of finding a counterpart for lighting on the public side in İstanbul was hopeful. After a chase of about 1 to 2 months, I managed to get the name of the department and of the director. Muhammet Garip, who had an academic background, had been appointed to head the department that would be founded under the name City Lighting and Energy Directorate. From that day on, we always had a good dialogue with Muhammet Bey, who got back to me as soon as he could when I asked him for an appointment, and who listened to me carefully throughout our long meeting. That day I talked at length about why lighting matters, about what openings it could bring in public space, about what we were doing in the magazine, about the PLDA association, about LUCI, and about events I wanted to organise that were still at the planning stage then. After this meeting, which took place in January 2007, we attended LUCI's meeting in Paris together in March, İstanbul then became a LUCI member, and in July we held our first lighting event as PLD Türkiye. After the 5 years that have passed, and the events we put our names to together in that time, I can comfortably say that I had met someone I see today as a friend.
In the time that passed, as I witnessed closely myself, the department under Muhammet Bey's lead worked in a self-sacrificing way, struggling to be in charge of lighting in a metropolis like İstanbul and to bring in a system. They kept up a pace of work fed by a vision that always took the “cities of light” as its example, and by a big goal such as producing an İstanbul Master Plan. This dream, which reached its peak with the İstanbul 2010 Capital of Culture project, sadly could not be brought to a conclusion, again because of that same project. At the point reached for bureaucratic reasons, lighting design tenders had been drawn up for only the 6 historic buildings that had been designated. Even though the tender processes were completed and the winners were known, even today not a single project has reached the implementation stage. I suppose this already pointed to the end of the department too. First, responsibility for the road lighting on the main arteries was handed to the electricity distribution companies. Then, as of the middle of this year, the department was abolished completely.
Frankly, I'm sad. I thought that once the positive results of the process that began with İstanbul were seen, it would spread to our other cities, and I had pinned many dreams on that structure, from light festivals to LUCI meetings, from a Master Plan to a lighting regulation. Sadly, it has disappeared. A step I saw as very important 5 years ago has been taken back too. Don't look far. There are studies, which we've published many times, that show in numbers the effects of light on our quality of life at the scale of a city. It's very painful for a city not to have a department in a subject that calls for expertise and that will affect, so deeply, not only safety but also socio-economic and cultural life. Now, the more I see what is happening in Ankara, and what is planned, the more horrified I am. The capital of Türkiye is being lit according to the personal taste of Mayor Melih Gökçek, and sadly no expert support is being brought in.
Is a return possible? Will a department open in İstanbul again? Or will some other city appear as an example? I don't know. But every municipality that does not close its eyes to what is happening outside this country's lands will one day feel a need like this. Let us hope it doesn't take very long.
Stay with the light until our next issue…
Emre Güneş
Professional Lighting Design Türkiye