Price Competition and Commission

· PLD Türkiye

Automatically translated from Turkish. Read the original

You'll remember that a few years ago a new kind of service appeared, called “Energy Efficiency Consultancy” (EVD). Thanks to support from the state, coordinated in particular by the General Directorate of Renewable Energy (YEG), we suddenly found ourselves coming across firms that offered this service. Under the Energy Efficiency Law, the EVDs authorised by YEG multiplied so fast that they quickly formed associations and spread across almost all of Türkiye.

The service they gave, simplified a little, was this: an engineer inspects your business, identifies the points where you use “too much” energy, and presents a report recommending systems and/or products that will do the same job while using less energy. The report also shows you how long it will take for the cost of your initial investment to pay for itself. That report is then combined with the initial-investment support and loans aimed at businesses, and a fast conversion is brought about.

Rough as that summary is, this was the situation. Today, sadly, many of the EVDs in question have either closed or set themselves apart by adding other services alongside. The reason is very simple: “Price competition.” The number of firms, growing fast and without any control, drove prices to such a point, in a kind of service whose quality could not be questioned, that no field was left where the firms could make money.

Why am I telling you all this? My fear is this: the lighting design profession too, though not exactly the same, faces the danger of entering a similar process. In today's conditions, who can give this service, and at what standard, is not under control. It doesn't look as if it will be in the near term either. That being so, in a kind of service that is hard to compare, price competition comes to the fore. There are even figures that reach my ear from the market such that starting to accept those figures as the standard would be the same as signing the profession's death warrant.

Today we know this: no service or product is free, and if the visible costs are not there, you are bearing the invisible ones. If you are quoted 10 TL and 200 TL for the same job, you have to keep in mind the other ways money might be made behind the 10 TL offer. And that brings us to that famous point, the “designer's commission”.

Commission, for architects included, is something that gets debated and much complained about. I respect everyone's stance and their thinking. My approach is this: if your client knows the money they pay you in return for the service they receive, there is no problem. But any earning made without the client's knowledge, and that the client has not approved, is in my view an unfair earning, whatever name it goes by.

My suggestion is simple: instead of complaining, first sweep in front of your own door. Invest in your brand, don't enter unfair price competition, differentiate your services and products, don't give or take a commission. That is, instead of complaining, you join the change too. Because change can begin only with you.

Stay with the light until our next issue...


PLD Türkiye